SUPERAGENT — Header
Stieber Insurance x SUPERAGENT AI

Three Locations. Every Call Answered. Customers Can't Tell It's AI.

About Stieber Insurance

Stieber Insurance Group is a family-owned independent insurance agency serving Texas since 1983, comparing multiple carriers to find every customer the best possible rate and policy.

Agency Footprint
Three locations serving Texas families and businesses
Industry
Property & Casualty Insurance, Independent Agency
Products Used
Live Call AI Agent  |  Quoting AI Agent (next)
Location
Fulshear, Richmond & Sweeny, Texas, United States of America
The Results: Live in a Week, Invisible by Design

A deliberately soft rollout went live on real customer calls. Within one week the agency was already seeing an evolution, while callers kept talking like nothing changed.

0
Locations, One Live Call AI Agent
1 wk
From Go-Live to Visible Evolution
0
Customers Lost in AI: Most Have No Clue
30–45
Min of Manual Entry per Home + Auto Quote, Next to Go
15–20
Min Back per Quote With AI Data Entry
24–48
Hr Quote Turnaround Being Compressed
Live Call AI Agent: To Answer Every Call, Human-First

The Client: Stieber Insurance Group

Stieber Insurance Group is a family-owned independent insurance agency that has been Texas insurance you can count on since 1983, with offices in Fulshear, Richmond, and Sweeny.

As an independent agency, Stieber quotes multiple carriers on every risk, running a detailed market search across auto, home, and business lines to make sure each customer gets the best possible rate and the best possible policy, not just one company's price.

Stieber Insurance
Suzanne Stieber-Loehr

About Suzanne Stieber-Loehr

Owner & Principal

Suzanne Stieber-Loehr is the owner and principal of Stieber Insurance Group, leading a three-location, family-owned independent agency in a market where finding, and keeping, qualified, engaged staff is the hardest problem in the business.

A self-described technology-driven owner, Suzanne went looking for an AI solution to her staffing challenge and chose SUPERAGENT with one non-negotiable: insurance is a relationship business, so customers should never feel they've traded a human for a machine.

Her rollout philosophy is simple: move early enough to win a competitive advantage, but roll it out so softly that customers only notice one thing: the agency got faster.

The Rollout Philosophy: Soft, Human, Invisible

Stieber didn't flip a switch. The agency rolled AI into live customer calls the way Suzanne insists it should be done:

Roll it out as softly as possible: little tweaks here and there, an evolution, not an explosion

Customers should never get lost in AI; they shouldn't even know there's AI involved

Start with specific use cases, then go one step further, and one step further again

Stay a relationship business: AI handles the transactional so the team can be the brains behind the machine

One week after go-live: some callers have an inkling, most have no clue, and the agency is simply responding quicker

Why Live Call AI Agent First

Live Call AI Agent was the starting point for three strategic reasons

Start 14-Day FREE TrialBook a Demo
It Solves the Hardest Hire
Finding qualified staff, and keeping them engaged, was Stieber's biggest constraint across three locations. The Live Call AI Agent answers every call without adding headcount.
Zero-Disruption Rollout
Live on real customer calls within days, tuned with little tweaks in production: a soft launch customers never felt.
Human-First by Design
Insurance is a relationship business. The agent sounds so natural that callers tell it their life stories; most can't tell the difference.

What's Next: The Quote Workflow, Before vs. With SUPERAGENT

WorkflowBefore SUPERAGENTWith SUPERAGENTWhy It Matters
Answering callsDependent on staffing across 3 officesLive Call AI answers instantly, human-firstEvery call answered, no new headcount
Data entry on quote callsTyped manually mid-conversation: "did I spell that right?"AI listens in and enters data in real timeAgents stay fully engaged with the customer
Auto quotesReal-time on the phone, slowed by manual entryAI-entered data feeds the quote instantlyFaster quotes = more business sold
Home + auto quotes30–45 min of entry; soft rate, then each carrier portal; 24–48 hr turnaroundQuoting AI eliminates the manual data entry so quotes are ready for CSR review15–20 min back on every quote
The Problem

The Challenge: Staffing Three Offices in a Tight Labor Market

Finding qualified staff was the agency's single hardest problem across three locations, and keeping the staff it had engaged was even harder.
Customers expect everything fast, "they almost want you to read their mind", but every call still depended on a human being available to pick up the phone.
As an independent agency, Stieber quotes multiple carriers on every risk: a detailed market search that takes real time on every single customer.
When a home was involved, manual data entry ran 30–45 minutes per home-and-auto quote, over and over, all day long: time that could have been spent talking to customers.
Rating platforms only produce soft numbers: they miss insurance scores and claims history, so staff still had to visit each carrier portal individually for the final rate, pushing home-quote turnaround to 24–48 hours.
Any fix had to protect the relationship: this is a business built on real connections, and customers should never feel like they've been handed to a machine.
Key Business Insights

What the First Weeks Revealed

Invisible AI Is the Best AI
Customers shouldn't know there's AI involved. One week in, some have an inkling; most have no clue.
Evolution, Not Revolution
Start with specific use cases, tweak in production, then go one step further. Flipping the switch overnight is how AI rollouts become disasters.
Speed Sells Policies
The faster you can turn a quote around, the more business you sell. Every minute of manual work is a quote a competitor gets to first.
Data Entry Is the Silent Tax
30–45 minutes of typing per home-and-auto quote, all day long. AI that listens and enters data gives 15–20 minutes back on every single quote.
Be the Brains Behind the Machine
Let AI take the transactional work so the team stops typing and starts advising: engaged with the customer, not the keyboard.
Get On Board Before the Train Leaves
Moving early is the competitive advantage: Suzanne's colleagues heard what Stieber is doing and are already calling SUPERAGENT.
Suzanne Stieber-Loehr
"I don't want my customer to get lost in AI. I don't even want them to know there's AI involved. I want them to think it's all human. We went live a week ago, and we have seen an evolution in just that short period of time."
Suzanne Stieber-Loehr
Owner & Principal, Stieber Insurance Group